Brooklyn Square Pizza
If you're ever in the mood for some mouthwatering pizza in Manalapan Township, NJ, look no further than Brooklyn Square Pizza. Located at 73 Wilson Ave, this cozy spot serves up some of the best square-shaped pies around, offering a delicious twist on classic pizza.
The atmosphere at Brooklyn Square Pizza is relaxed and welcoming, making it a great choice for both families and groups. Whether you're stopping by for a quick bite or enjoying a meal with loved ones, the casual vibe makes it the perfect place to hang out. Kids love the friendly environment, and it’s ideal for a laid-back dinner with friends or family.
When it comes to the menu, there are a few standout dishes that you absolutely have to try. The Upside Down Pie is a local favorite, with layers of flavorful sauce and cheese topped off with a crispy, golden crust. If you're craving a more traditional pizza, the Square Slice and Brooklyn Square Pie are sure to hit the spot. But for a truly unique experience, go for the Sophia Loren — a pizza that’s just as sophisticated as its name suggests. And of course, the Square Upside Down Pizza is another crowd-pleaser, offering a savory, cheesy bite in every square slice.
No matter what you choose, you're guaranteed to get a hearty, satisfying meal. The pizza here is made with quality ingredients, baked to perfection, and served in generous portions that will leave you full and happy.
So next time you’re in the area, make sure to swing by Brooklyn Square Pizza for a slice of deliciousness. It's not just about the pizza — it's about the experience, the vibe, and the people you’re sharing it with.
Reviews
You like Sicilian Pizza......then this is worth the drive to get!! This is by far the BEST Sicilian style pizza we have ever had. We live in Lakeland, FL, but when in town to visit family, this is one if our "Must Stops"!!
not pictured here but also had the pepperoni sicilian slice. That was really good. Also had the chicken caesar salad slice which wasn't bad either. Great pizza here
So this review is just for the upside down Sicilian dine-in, but, WOW, I LOVE this pizza! The sauce was awesome both flavor-wise and texturally (ever-so-slightly chunky, which I love), the cheese was perfectly melted, and that dough thoooooo. Very slight crisp on the bottom but overall doughy and chewy, which is EXACTLY what I like (but understand that's not everyone's preference). I love when there's some weight behind the dough and it's not just completely airy floof. Our server was also sooo friendly and even offered to move us to a larger table to help make the pizza not feel so crammed on our table even though we were just two people. A fair amount of seating inside, I would say maybe for 20ish people. It's a good thing we live so far away, otherwise, we'd probably be here once a week. Highly recommend!
I take this seriously. Absolutely the best chicken Marsala I have had in a restaurant. It hit that comfort space and I left feeling great. It came with a big salad, hot bread and spaghetti. I also bought a Nonna square pie for later and lunch. Would recommend this place all day long.
Best pizza in Manalapan area. Service was fantastic and friendly. Arancini was huge and delicious.